Skip to content

For everybody to get a habitable home...

Recommendations


Immediate Justice for Dalmarnock Village

The evidence presented throughout this report demonstrates that many residents have already borne unacceptable financial, physical, and emotional costs as a consequence of prolonged housing failure. Justice therefore requires more than acknowledgement. It requires immediate action to remedy unsafe housing conditions, provide restitution for avoidable harm, and reimburse residents for the financial burdens imposed by institutional failure.

Establish an Independent Dalmarnock Village Remediation Programme

The Scottish Government should establish an independent Dalmarnock Village Remediation Programme to identify, investigate, and permanently remedy housing defects across Dalmarnock Village.

The initiative should be supported by appropriate funding, independent governance arrangements, and statutory powers to ensure that all relevant organisations fully cooperate. Housing providers, developers, contractors, Glasgow City Council, and all other relevant organisations should be placed under a statutory duty to cooperate fully. This should include providing unrestricted access to repair histories, maintenance records, technical reports, procurement information, contractors, relevant communal areas, and senior decision-makers, and facilitating access to individual properties where residents have voluntarily chosen to participate in the programme.

The Remediation Programme should include:

  • Independent stock condition surveys for every household (social housing tenants, private tenants, and owner-occupiers) wishing to participate, including intrusive investigations where necessary and with residents’ consent. Any areas disturbed during investigations must be fully reinstated at no cost to residents;
  • A dedicated and fully funded programme of remedial works, with publicly available plans, clear timescales, milestones and named responsibilities;
  • Emergency intervention for households experiencing structural or environmental conditions that present an immediate risk to health or safety;

The Remediation Programme should be overseen by a Community Remediation Committee comprising residents from across the Village and reflecting its different housing tenures, communities, and lived experiences, including both social housing tenants and owner-occupiers. The Committee should be constituted through an open, transparent, and representative process trusted by the local community, with access to independent technical, legal, and community support where required. It should not serve as a consultative body, but should exercise genuine democratic authority over the oversight and strategic direction of the Remediation Programme. The Community Remediation Committee should establish appropriate mechanisms to enable residents who do not wish to be publicly identified to participate confidentially in its work and to submit evidence, concerns, and proposals without fear of retaliation.

The Community Remediation Committee should have the power to:

  • Scrutinise all survey findings and proposed remedial works;
  • Approve and revise the framework used to prioritise repairs and remediation;
  • Require housing providers, contractors, developers, public bodies, and other relevant organisations to attend public meetings and explain delays, failures, or disputed decisions;
  • Commission independent technical advice or engineering inspections where residents dispute survey findings or completed works;
  • Monitor delivery through regular public meetings and progress reviews;
  • Publish independent assessments of the programme’s performance together with recommendations for further action.

Where communication or engagement between the Community Remediation Committee and any relevant organisation breaks down, the Scottish Government should be required to convene formal resolution meetings to restore effective working arrangements and ensure the continued delivery of the Remediation Programme.

Restitution for Residents

Justice requires more than repairing buildings. It requires repairing the harm those failures inflicted upon the people forced to live with them. Housing providers should provide comprehensive restitution to residents who experienced prolonged disrepair as a consequence of institutional failures.

Restitution should extend beyond damaged belongings and include compensation for:

  • Years spent living with defective housing;
  • Loss of use of rooms and facilities;
  • Avoidable financial costs;
  • Repeated failed repairs;
  • Deterioration in physical and mental health, and wellbeing;
  • Unnecessary distress caused by institutional failures.

As part of the Dalmarnock Village Remediation Programme, every participating household should receive an independent assessment of the harm experienced and any entitlement to restitution. Entitlement to restitution should be determined through an independent assessment process applying transparent and publicly available criteria. Housing providers, developers, contractors, or other organisations found to bear responsibility should be required to implement restitution awards within a specified statutory timescale.

The Community Remediation Committee should oversee the operation of the restitution process and monitor the implementation of awards, but should not determine individual awards.

Rent Rebates for Unusable Homes and Rooms

Charging full rent for a partially unusable home transfers the costs of institutional failure onto the households forced to live with it.

Housing association tenants should receive proportionate rent rebates where parts of their home were unusable due to unresolved disrepair, flooding, mould, failed plumbing, structural defects, or other serious housing failures.

The Dalmarnock Village Remediation Programme should independently assess entitlement to rent rebates as part of its investigation of each participating household. Where periods of partial or complete loss of use are established, housing providers should be required to repay the appropriate proportion of rent within a specified statutory timescale.

The Community Remediation Committee should oversee the operation of the rent rebate scheme, monitor compliance by housing providers, and publish regular reports on its implementation, but should not determine individual entitlements.

Building a More Accountable Housing System

The failures documented throughout this report exposed weaknesses within Scotland’s wider system of housing regulation, repairs, accountability, and tenant protection. While the recommendations that follow do not seek to replace that system, they would significantly strengthen it by improving accountability, empowering residents, and ensuring that persistent housing failures are identified and addressed far earlier than they are today.

The purpose of these reforms is not simply to improve the administration of housing services, but to establish a housing system in which every person can expect a home that is safe, warm, dry, secure, affordable, and maintained to a consistently high standard, with effective rights and democratic accountability where those standards are not met.

Independent Evidence for Housing Regulation

The relationship between landlord and tenant is characterised by a significant imbalance of power. Residents may reasonably fear that openly criticising the organisation responsible for managing their home could affect future interactions, complaint handling, or their wider relationship with their landlord. The use of external survey companies does not, in itself, guarantee independence where housing providers remain responsible for commissioning assessments of their own performance.

The Scottish Government should establish an independent national system for measuring tenant experience across Scotland’s social housing sector. The disconnect between reported performance and residents’ lived experiences raises serious questions about the reliability of landlord-generated satisfaction measures and aggregate performance indicators as a basis for regulatory scrutiny. Independent regulation requires independent, transparent, and sufficiently detailed evidence capable of identifying persistent housing failures and institutional patterns over time, enabling the Scottish Housing Regulator to investigate systemic failures and take effective regulatory action where necessary.

This should include:

  • Independent commissioning and administration of tenant experience and satisfaction surveys;
  • Standardised survey methodologies applied consistently across all social landlords;
  • Direct reporting of survey findings to the Scottish Housing Regulator;
  • Publication of full survey results, methodology, response rates, and anonymised datasets;
  • Independent analysis of trends in tenant experience over time;
  • Statutory protection to ensure that participation is confidential and cannot affect tenants’ relationship with their housing provider.

National Standard for Recording Housing Repairs

Scotland should establish a national standard for recording housing repairs that distinguishes between completed repairs and unresolved recurring defects. A repair should not be regarded as complete simply because work has been undertaken. Where the same defect, or a closely related defect, recurs repeatedly, housing providers should record it as an ongoing housing failure rather than a series of separate completed repairs.

The national standard should require:

  • Standardised recording of repair histories across all social housing providers;
  • Clear procedures for identifying recurring defects, reviewing previous repair attempts and escalating them for further investigation;
  • Public reporting of recurring repair failures as part of housing performance information.

Residents’ Right to Property Repair Histories

Residents should have a statutory right to access the complete repair and defect history of the home in which they live. Information about the condition and repair history of a property should belong not only to the housing provider, but also to the people whose lives are directly affected by it.

Housing providers should therefore maintain and make available a comprehensive property record, including:

  • Previous repair requests and completed works;
  • Outstanding and unresolved defects;
  • Technical surveys, inspections, and investigation reports;
  • Records of intrusive investigations;
  • Planned and completed remedial works;
  • Relevant information concerning recurring defects affecting the property.

The repair and defect record should also be securely accessible to authorised repair contractors, surveyors, and other relevant professionals, enabling them to review previous repairs, technical investigations, recurring defects, and remedial works before attending a property.

Residents should be able to access this information without unnecessary delay or administrative barriers, including when moving into a property, requesting repairs, pursuing complaints, or bringing legal proceedings.

Financial Protection during Repairs

Residents should never be required to incur avoidable financial loss in order to access repairs or cooperate with investigations into housing defects.

Housing providers should ensure that repair processes do not leave residents financially worse off as a condition of remedial works. Where repairs require flooring, furnishings, decorations, or other property to be removed, damaged, or replaced, housing providers should bear the reasonable costs arising from those works.

A resident’s decision to postpone, decline, or disengage from proposed repairs should not be recorded as ‘customer choice’ or refusal where that decision results from the financial consequences of repeated repair failures or the absence of adequate protection against further loss. In such circumstances, housing providers should instead record that participation has been prevented by the absence of appropriate arrangements for the protection, like-for-like reinstatement, or replacement of residents’ property, and should resolve those issues before recording repairs as refused or declined.

Collective Insurance for Social Housing Tenants

Social housing providers should ensure that all tenants are protected against financial losses arising from housing defects, major repair failures, flooding, or other failures for which the provider bears responsibility. This protection should not depend upon tenants purchasing optional insurance products or navigating complex claims processes. Housing providers should instead establish collective arrangements that ensure residents are compensated promptly where institutional failures cause damage to personal belongings or unavoidable financial loss.

National Standard for Repair Appointments

Residents should be entitled to a professional, reliable, and accountable repairs service.

Repair systems should respect residents’ time as well as their homes. Residents should not be expected to continually use annual leave, lose income, or remain at home for prolonged periods because of poor coordination between housing providers and contractors.

National service standards should therefore require:

  • Clearly defined appointment windows with a specified maximum duration;
  • Prompt notification of delays or cancellations;
  • Automatic compensation where appointments are missed without reasonable notice;
  • Improved communication between housing providers and contractors;
  • Repair instructions that accurately reflect the complexity and nature of reported defects.

These standards should reflect established best practice across other regulated sectors, including energy and utilities, where defined appointment windows, service standards, and automatic compensation for missed appointments are already well established.

Public Funding Should Require Public Accountability

Public funds should not continue to be paid to housing providers persistently failing to meet their legal obligations.

The Scottish Government should review arrangements whereby Housing Benefit and the housing element of Universal Credit are paid directly to social landlords, with the aim of ensuring that tenants whose housing costs are met through public funds enjoy equally effective means of holding landlords accountable for prolonged or serious housing failures.

Where independent investigation establishes persistent and unresolved breaches of landlords’ statutory repairing obligations, mechanisms should exist to allow the temporary withholding, redirection, or escrow of public housing payments until appropriate remedial action has been taken, accompanied by appropriate safeguards to protect tenants from financial detriment.

Addressing the Imbalance of Power in Housing Complaints and Disputes

Residents should not be disadvantaged in enforcing their housing rights simply because they lack the financial resources, legal representation, technical expertise, or institutional resources available to housing providers. Access to justice and effective redress should not depend upon a resident’s ability to obtain expert evidence, navigate complex complaints procedures, or bear the financial costs of challenging a housing provider.

The Scottish Government should review the housing complaints and redress system, including Stage 1 and Stage 2 complaints procedures and the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman, to ensure residents can secure effective, timely and enforceable remedies without facing disproportionate procedural, evidential or financial barriers. This should include establishing a statutory duty for housing providers to proactively inform residents of their housing rights and available routes to redress.

To address these inequalities, the Scottish Government should ensure that the housing complaints and redress system provides for:

  • Complaints procedures that are proportionate, accessible and designed to investigate and resolve housing failures rather than create unnecessary procedural or administrative barriers to residents seeking redress;
  • Greater access for residents to publicly funded independent technical assessments, expert reports and professional advice where specialist evidence is required to establish the cause, extent or consequences of housing defects;
  • Mechanisms to ensure that residents are not required to bear unreasonable financial costs in obtaining independent expert evidence where this is necessary to challenge the findings or technical evidence relied upon by a housing provider;
  • Appropriate resourcing for independent advice organisations to provide housing advice, advocacy and representation, recognising that improvements in access to justice are likely to increase demand for independent support;
  • A requirement that allegations attributing housing defects to resident behaviour be supported by clear and independent technical evidence, with the burden resting upon housing providers to establish that resident behaviour is responsible where the cause of a defect is disputed;
  • Recognition of residents’ lived experience as an important form of evidence alongside technical assessments when investigating housing disputes and institutional failures;
  • Clear, accessible guidance and practical support for residents throughout complaints and redress processes, including information about their legal rights, available routes to redress and the evidence that may be required;
  • A requirement for housing providers to supply clear information about the Tolerable Standard, repair rights and responsibilities, complaints procedures, Housing and Property Chamber remedies, and access to independent inspections and advice. Where a property is found to fall below the Tolerable Standard or other relevant legal requirements, residents must be formally notified in writing of the breach, the findings of the investigation and the remedial action proposed.

Collective Complaints and Collective Redress

The Scottish Government should create formal mechanisms for collective housing complaints and collective redress.

Where multiple residents report the same or closely related housing defects within the same development, neighbourhood, block, or housing provider’s stock, those complaints should give rise to a presumption that the matter requires investigation as a potential systemic housing failure, rather than being treated as unrelated individual cases.

Residents should be able to bring collective complaints with the support of advice agencies, tenant unions, community organisations, and local authorities.

Where a collective complaint is accepted, housing providers should be required to investigate the wider causes of the reported failures across the affected homes, rather than limiting investigations solely to the individual properties from which complaints originated.

Where systemic failure is established, housing providers should be required to develop and implement collective remedial action plans rather than relying solely upon the resolution of individual complaints.

Strengthening the Implementation of Awaab’s Law

Awaab’s Law should mark the beginning of a wider transformation in housing accountability rather than the end of it. The legislation should provide the foundation for a broader system of housing accountability capable of addressing the full range of serious housing failures experienced by residents.

The Scottish Government should keep the operation, scope, and effectiveness of Awaab’s Law under regular review, ensuring that its protections continue to develop in light of residents’ experiences and emerging evidence.

This should include:

  • Extending equivalent statutory duties, timescales, and enforcement mechanisms to a wider range of serious housing defects, including flooding, drainage failures, plumbing failures, ventilation failures, structural defects, and recurring repair failures;
  • Access to independent technical inspections and investigations where the existence or cause of a housing hazard is disputed, or where concerns arise regarding the adequacy of a landlord’s investigation or proposed remedial works;
  • Strong protection against retaliation or detriment for residents who report housing hazards;
  • Clear and accessible routes to independent enforcement where landlords fail to comply;
  • Effective sanctions for persistent non-compliance;
  • Compensation and other appropriate remedies where statutory duties are breached;
  • Meaningful resident participation in reviewing the operation, implementation, and future development of the legislation;
  • Housing providers should demonstrate that repairs services, whether delivered directly or through external contractors, are adequately resourced, supervised, and quality assured to meet statutory repair obligations.

Democratic Public Ownership of Social Housing

Social housing should be publicly owned and democratically governed.

Scotland should begin a long-term transition towards bringing social housing back into public ownership, reversing decades in which public housing has been fragmented across institutions that are remote from the communities they serve and insulated from meaningful democratic control by the people whose homes they govern.

Public ownership would allow housing to be planned and provided at the scale required: pooling resources, expertise and risk; coordinating major repairs and investment; maintaining professional services; building new homes; and directing resources according to need rather than the capacity or priorities of individual landlords.

But public ownership alone is not enough.

A publicly owned housing system can itself become remote, bureaucratic and unresponsive if ownership is simply transferred while power remains concentrated within distant institutions. Bringing social housing back into public ownership must therefore be accompanied by a fundamental democratisation of how public housing is governed.

The objective should be public ownership with resident power: combining the collective capacity of the public sector with meaningful democratic control by the people and communities who live within it.

Bring Social Housing Back into Public Ownership

The Scottish Government should establish a long-term national programme to progressively bring housing association stock back into public ownership.

This should be supported by the legislation, public investment and financial arrangements necessary to deliver an orderly transition while protecting tenants and maintaining housing services.

The purpose should not be to change the name above the door while preserving the same concentration of power underneath it. Existing housing associations should not simply be recreated as publicly owned institutions operating at the same distance from residents.

Bringing social housing back into public ownership should create a coherent public housing system capable of planning, investing and delivering at scale, pooling resources across communities and responding decisively when serious housing failures emerge.

Public ownership should also expand through substantial new social housing construction and the public acquisition of homes and land.

The long-term objective should be clear: social housing should be a permanent public asset, owned collectively and provided according to social need.

Local Democratic Power within a Public Housing System

Public ownership must be accompanied by a redistribution of power.

Residents should have guaranteed democratic power within local housing governance, including meaningful authority over local investment priorities, major planned works, neighbourhood management, regeneration and housing service standards, alongside the ability to scrutinise and hold housing services publicly accountable.

This power should be embedded within the governance of public housing itself. Residents should not be confined to consultation exercises or tenant panels while the institutions controlling resources and making decisions retain the final say.

At the same time, public ownership should provide the scale necessary to pool resources, finance investment, build homes, undertake major structural works and maintain professional expertise. A community facing serious housing failure should not be constrained by the finances or capacity of an individual landlord. Resources should be shared across the public housing system and directed according to need.

Democratic control does not mean asking residents to administer housing services themselves. Professional bodies should remain responsible for repairs, construction, finance and other specialist functions, while residents exercise democratic power over their priorities and direction.

The principle should be simple: resources pooled collectively; power exercised democratically and as locally as possible.

Public Investment Should Build Public Wealth

Public money should build permanent public wealth.

New social housing substantially funded by the state should remain in public ownership. Public land used for housing should remain publicly owned wherever possible, and government should expand public acquisition of land required for future housing and community development.

The same principle should apply to regeneration.

Communities should not experience cycles in which enormous public investment improves land, infrastructure and neighbourhoods only for the resulting value and assets to pass out of public control. Where the public creates value, the public should retain it.

Housing, land and infrastructure created through collective investment should become part of the permanent material wealth of society, available to meet present and future social need.

Public ownership should therefore extend beyond individual homes. Land determines where housing can be built, how communities develop and who ultimately benefits from investment. A democratic housing system requires the public to possess the land and resources necessary to shape that development in the public interest.

The expansion of public housing should therefore form part of a wider expansion of public ownership of housing and land, governed in the public interest and subject to democratic control.

From Tenants to Citizens: A Democratic Right to the City

The principles of democratic public ownership should extend beyond the governance of social housing. People experience their homes as part of wider communities shaped by decisions about land, development, public space, infrastructure and regeneration. These decisions can fundamentally alter neighbourhoods and the lives of the people within them, yet communities frequently exercise little meaningful power over them.

Scotland should therefore recognise a Right to the City, establishing the principle that communities should have meaningful democratic power in shaping the development and future of the places in which they live. This should extend to major decisions concerning regeneration, development, land use, public space, community assets and neighbourhood investment.

Such a right would require moving beyond conventional models of community participation. Consultation can provide opportunities for residents to express their views, but the final authority to determine priorities and make decisions remains elsewhere. A democratic approach should instead give communities a meaningful share of decision-making power over changes that substantially affect their neighbourhoods.

This does not mean that every planning, housing or infrastructure decision should be made directly by residents. Public institutions would continue to have responsibilities extending across communities, while professional and technical expertise would remain essential. The principle is that these responsibilities should not exclude the people most directly affected from sharing democratic authority over the future of their communities.

Taken together with the democratic public ownership of social housing, this would establish a broader understanding of housing democracy: one in which residents have meaningful power not only over the institutions governing their homes, but over the development of the communities in which they live. It would recognise people not simply as tenants or service users, but as citizens with a democratic stake in the places they call home.